A witchy one on one (closed)

Tolly hummed quietly as he thought about it, eventually pecking Cas on the cheek and pulling away. "Sure, sounds fun!"

Cas took Tolly's hand in his and led him out the back door towards the gardens that grew by the side of the house

Tolly took in the garden with a smile, excited to be outside as night was starting to fall. "This place is so pretty! Um… What do we need to get?"

"the flowers that are fully bloomed. We can collect the pollen and nectar tomorrow." He said glancing around flowers. "They'll glow in the dark."

Tolly gasped and rushed forward into the garden, entranced by the glowing flowers. He'd never seen anything like this before. "Cool!"

Cas smiled at Tolly's fascination and picked up a gathering basket. He sat down and started to carefully sigh up the flowers.

Tolly picked the one he'd been mooning over after a few seconds, setting it carefully into the basket. "How many do we need?"

"Around 15. Not many." He said, picking some more of the flowers, their soft glow casting shadows on his arm and face as he inspected the flower

Tolly paused to admire Cas's profile in the flower's dim light, smiling at him with something soft and loving in his eyes. He strolled over and wrapped his arm's around Cas' shoulders. "You're so pretty. I don't tell you that enough."

He turned around in his grasp and smiled "yes you do." He booped him on the nose with the flower, laughing as some of the pollen stuck.

Tolly wrinkled his nose and brushed it off, laughing along with Cas. "I should definitely say it more you liar. You deserve it."

Cas blushed, grateful for the darkness. "You deserve it too, beautiful one." He said softly, gazing you at him lovingly

Tolly flushed and dropped his gaze, kissing Cas a few seconds later with a pout. "That's not fair, you can just look at me like that and compliment me! How am I supposed to compete?"

He chuckled lightly "it's not a competition if you already won, pretty one." He said, snuggling against Tolly

Tolly's blush darkened and he pulled Cas closer. "I did not! You're a hundred times prettier than me."

"nope, you are." He said, glancing up at him "I don't give up easily so you might as well accept it."

"I'm not giving up until you realize that you're the pretty one!" Tolly pulled him closer, a playfully determined gleam in his eyes. "Just accept that."

Cas rested his hand on tolly's chest and shoulder, the same determination glittering his eyes "I will never accept that."

Tolly laughed and set his hand over Cas', raising it to his lips with a pleased smile. "But sweetheart, it's the truth."

Cas gazed up at tolly with an adoring look "then what I've come to believe has been a lie? That I've fallen in love with the most beautiful person in the world?"

Tolly blushed a bright red and hid his face in Cas' shoulder, arm's tightening minutely around his waist. "Yes." His words were slightly muffled. "Because I'm in love with the most beautiful, caring, wonderful person in the world and he's in my arms right now."

He sighed in defeat and nuzzled Tolly's head "fine," he said softly "you win. For now at least."

Tolly laughed and looked up at him, a dazzling smile on his face and a slight blush on his cheeks. "Of course I won, I've got all the facts."

Cas rolled his eyes playfully "you didn't have any facts, you just took my words and twisted them so they fit your argument."

Tolly pecked him on the cheek. "Nuh-uh! I took your words and fixed them so they were true. I won anyways, so you have to accept that you're the prettiest."

Cas huffed to hide a smile and shook his head "no, I don't wanna accept it."

"Too bad." Tolly leaned over and kissed him, smiling playfully. "You already admitted defeat."

"yes I did,doesn't mean I have to accept the outcome." A traitorous smile spread across his lips

Tolly gasped in mock betrayal and put a hand over his heart. "No fair! That's cheating, Cas. Play by the rules."

He broke into a laugh "you never established the rules love, how was I supposed to know?"