A witchy one on one (closed)

"Whatever you say, Hon," Tolly replied, opening his laptop with a grateful smile. "Thanks by the way! You're a real lifesaver."

"uh huh, sure." He muttered, keeping his head fowards. He wrote down his own notes and decided to re-write the copy at his dorm, hoping Tolly or Levi didn't mind the delay

Tolly tuned into the lecture, surprised by how interested he was once he actually started paying attention. The three hours flew by and before he knew it, people were packing up and heading out of the room and Cait was shaking Levi awake. He turned to Cas. "Got the notes?"

Cas turned to Tolly "I'll have them done by tonight. I'll give them to you in the morning before we get to class." He said While packing up his things

Tolly nodded, a grateful smile stretched across his face. "Perfect! Thanks for all your hel-"

"Tolly!" Cait yelled, interrupting his sentence. He turned with a questioning look on his face and Cait shoved a corked bottle full of something pink into his hands. "Drink it. I wanna see if it'll work."

"That's sketchy as hell Cait," Tolly replied already opening the bottle, "But you're my bestie so I'll do it." He took a sniff of the potion and then, suspicions ignored, downed it in a single gulp. It tasted like roses and sugar and made him feel warm. He looked up, happy with the effect, and locked eyes with Cas.

"oh shit…." Cas backed away slowly "you couldn't clear everyone out of the room before you gave it to him?" He said to Cait, "or stand in front of him." Once Cas got to the classroom door, he made a run for it, hoping his one year in track could get him to his dorm fast enough before Tolly could find him "not good, not good, not good…"

Tolly frowned, immediately standing up to follow Cas. Why was he leaving? He jogged out the door, breaking into an all-out sprint once he reached the hallway. He'd been running cross country for years, and quickly caught up with Cas, tackling him to the ground. "Hi," he breathed, smiling.

Cas let out a yell in surprise and struggled against Tolly "hi Tolly, mind getting off me please?" He asked, blushing furiously while trying to break away.

"Why?" Tolly asked, tilting his head innocently. Cas was so nice and warm and pretty and Tolly never wanted to move again.

Cas stopped moving, giving up for now and gazed up at Tolly "cuz we're in the middle of campus." He said "what about Cait? I'm sure she's worried sick looking for you. Let's go find her and talk."

"But I wanna be with you. Not Cait." Tolly frowned, sitting up and pulling Cas into his lap to cuddle him. "Don't you wanna be with me?"

"but we have to go find her, she's probably worried." He avoided the second question, not wanting to hurt Tolly but also not knowing how to answer the question, he liked Levi bit he'd always felt more comfortable around Tolly for some reason, sticking close to him I. Crowds instead of anyone else. He sighed softly, dismissing it as one of the side effects the potion had on both the user and the other participant. "Fine, how about we head back to my dorm. We'll write up the notes for Levi and then we talk to Cait, sound good?"

Tolly smiled brightly, nuzzling Cas's cheek for a second before he stood, lifting Cas up in his arms to carry him princess style. "As long as I can be with you!"

He squeaked in surprise and instinctully wrapped his arms around Tolly's neck "ok, mind putting me down, though? I'm fine to walk." he said, glancing over at him and pulling away a bit, realizing how close he was to Tolly

"But I wanna hold you," Tolly pouted, starting to walk down the hall. "You're so perfect, you deserve to be carried around everywhere."

Cas sighed not wanting to draw attention to himself "How about this, you can hold me when we get the dorm while we I re-write the notes, okay? for now, we can walk."

"Okay!" Tolly smiled brightly as he set Cas on the ground, careful to make sure he didn't lose his balance. "Can I still hold your hand?"

He thought it over and nodded "Fine," he silently chastised himself for accepting but didn't know what else to do until he could get to the shop later that night or talk to cait.

Tolly beamed, grabbing Cas's hand and dropping a kiss to their linked fingers. Whenever he touched Cas, things felt fuzzy and warm and he never wanted to stop. "Thank you!"

His glanced away so Tolly didn't see the bright blush on his cheeks "Uh…no..no..problem," he stuttered, starting to walk in the direction of the dorms he stayed at

Tolly smiled indulgently at him for the entire walk to the dorm, grinning excitedly as they reached the building. "Let's go inside! I wanna cuddle with you."

Cas tried to keep his eyes averted for most of the walk, knowing if he looked up, he'd blush more. Some part of him reveled in the look Tolly was giving him, having never been looked at like that before. He pulled out his student ID and swiped against the scanner, granting him access to the room. he opened the dorr and set his things down, letting go of Tolly's hand to grab a snack "You want anything to eat?" he asked from the small in-dorm kitchen

Tolly frowned when Cas dropped his hand, wandering into the kitchen after him and draping his arms over Cas's shoulders. "You?" he murmured, leaning forward to nip playfully at his ear.

He blushed again, the red reaching the tips of his ears and a warm sensation crept up his neck "I…i meant..food wise.." a light shiver ran along his back. Cas cursed his body for being so traitorous

Tolly frowned, pressing a kiss to the soft skin behind his ear and fiddling with the hem of his shirt. "But I don't want any food. You on the other hand…"

He swallowed hard and breathed from his mouth "no…no…not now, please…." he pleaded softly "tolly please not now."

Once Tolly heard the quiver in Cas's voice, he pulled away. Seeing Cas sad made something dark and ashamed flow through him. "I'm sorry! Are you okay? Did I go too far?"

He shook his head "no, I'm just confused and I'd rather not rush into things. Let's just take it slow, okay?" He said, glancing over his shoulder at Tolly

Tolly nodded enthusiastically, wrapping his arms around Cas's waist now that he knew it was okay to touch again. "Why are you confused? You know that I like you, right? Because I really really do!"

Cas sighed and leaned into him, letting him indulge a the affection "Tolly, you're under a spell. You won't remember any of this after a week. Everything you say or do is just the potion taking effect."