A witchy one on one (closed)

Tolly returned the adoration with a smile that was almost shy, pressing his face into Cas' shoulder so he wouldn't have to deal with all the gentle affection being aimed at him. He let out a sigh as he was nudged up, but the kiss was returned enthusiastically and he gathered up his papers without any protest. "Yeah, I think you're right. I'll turn them in tomorrow, I don't wanna miss getting to hang out with you."

“You wouldn’t love, I’m not going anywhere.” He stood and stretched, watching as more glitter fell from his hair. “Do you mind if I shower quickly? I’m starting to get sick of the glitter.” He said with a laugh, trying his best not to move so much. “I can always run to my dorm if not, I think I might need some clothes anyways.”

Tolly laughed quietly, doing his best to try and brush the glitter off his furniture. It didn't work out super well, but it was the thought that counted and anyways, it was helping a little. "Yeah, that's just fine. You know where the bathroom is right?" He glanced up at Cas with a soft smile. "Cause you're cute, but I don't wanna go into the shower with you just yet."

He laughed and shook his head “to grab clothes love, not to shower together.” He turned away to hide his reddening blush blush and nodded “yeah, I know where it is, thank you.” He headed off towards the bathroom, assuming it was in the same spot as the one he had. He slipped inside and started running the water so it would be warm.

Tolly hooked a hand around Cas's waist and pulled him in for one last kiss before he let him go. "Alright! I'll be waiting around here when you get out, m'kay?" Even though he'd finished up with his math, he still had work from other classes to get through. Lots of notes, mostly, since midterms were coming up.

Cas topped into the shower after pulling off his glitter covered clothes. He relaxed into the warmth of the shower, shutting his eyes and relaxing his body after a few moments. The red on his cheeks still hadn’t faded from the kiss or what Tolly had said before. He washed out his hair as much as possible, trying his best to get the majority of the glitter. By the time he had stepped out of the shower, he had a light sheen of excess glitter on him burn he hadn’t gotten most of it out. He pulled on his clothes that he was wearing when he had gotten there and stepped out of the barroom, feeling refreshed.

Tolly was, true to his word, settled comfortably on the couch, a small smile on his face as he laughed along to the show he was watching. Unlike Cas, he had plenty of clothes on hand so he'd changed into something a bit more comfortable than the clothes he worse to class—some soft grey sweats and a stretched out white tank top that showed off the muscle in his arms. He glanced up when he saw Cas wander out, giving him a bright smile as he patted the cushion beside him. "Hey! You look good, shower did wonders for your hair."

He laughed softly and plopped down next to Tolly, curling up beside him and resting his head on his shoulder. “It did, way less glittery than before, though now it’s going to be fluffy and a tangled mess in the morning.” He shrugged and took a peek at what was on TV, though not really paying much attention to it.

Tolly smiled and wrapped an arm around Cas's shoulders, pulling him in close. He nuzzled up against the crook of his neck, drinking in the scent of his shampoo with a pleased little noise. "It's fine, it looks cute. And better yet, it doesn't smell like plastic anymore, it smells like me."

Cas leaned into him a bit more and pressed a gentle kiss his Tolly’s head. “You’re most defiantly right. I’ll take smelling like you over glitter any day of the week.” He nudged Tolly’s head gently and ruffled his hair

Tolly leaned into the kiss with a warm smile, soaking up the affection like a very happy sponge. "I'm glad that we can agree, then. We… um…" He cuddled a little closer, tossed an arm around Cas' waist. "… we were doing something earlier, weren't we?"

He hummed softly and leaned into his hold. “Were we now? What exactly were we doing love? I can’t seem to recall.” He murmured, leaning as close as he could without kissing the other.

Tolly closed the space between them with a small smile, kissing Cas sweetly. "I can't tell if you're teasing me or not," he murmured, letting his forehead rest against Cas' once they had pulled apart. "You're hard to read, you're always so sincere."

Cas leaned into Tolly’s kiss, returning it happily with a little pout when he broke away. “I was teasing. Just a bit.” He admitted with a laugh, curling up closer to Tolly and pressing small kisses to his lips and jaw. “I never meant any harm love, only to receive your affection.”

Tolly laughed quietly and tilted his head back a little, a silent invitation for Cas to keep going. "You can always just ask, you know." His voice was soft, playful. Clearly he didn't mind being messed with, as long as it was all in good fun. "I'm not going to say no, I love being sweet with you."

Cas hummed softly and continued to pressed kisses to Tolly’s exposed neck. “If I recall correctly, you were the one who questioned what we were doing, darling. Though I suppose I could have been more direct with my answer.” He nudged Tolly’s head affectionately and pressed a slow kiss to his lips.

Tolly let out a happy sound and craned his neck a little further, obviously drinking in the affection. He sighed happily when he was nudged into a soft kiss, tossing an arm around Cas' neck to hold him close. "I think I would've remembered if we were doing this, is all." He pressed a little closer, a small smile on his face. "But I can't say I'm opposed to this."

“As would I, or at least if Hope I’d remember.” He agreed with a small chuckle as Tolly leaned in closer. “Neither am I, dear.” He murmured, pressing feather light kisses to Tolly’s lips

Tolly grinned beneath the shower of attention, laughing quietly before he leaned back a little and tugged Cas into his lap. They were pressed close like that, chest to chest. Cas was so warm, he couldn't help but purr with happiness. "You're the best, you know that?"

“Me? I think you meant to say you, darling. I’m far from the best. Though I appreciate it.” He said, a light blush on his cheeks. He smiled softly down at Tolly and pressed a longer kiss to his lips, drawing it out more than the last few and digging his hand so into his hair to hold him close. “you're the best. Friend, boyfriend, person, everything. I don’t what’s I’d do if I hadn’t met you.”

Tolly leaned into the kiss eagerly and kissed back harder as Cas tangled a hand in his hair, letting out a breathless little noise. "Oh, that…" He pulled away a little, a hazy smile on his face. "That's really nice of you to say, Cas, but I know what I meant. I…" He seemed distracted, almost, by the way Cas was holding him close. Kept going back to it in his head, how nice it felt. "… I really do think you're the best. You help everyone out and you're so nice and you… you never have a bad word to say about anyone. I think that makes you a good contender."

He smiled softly and pressed a gentle kiss to his brow. He had never really been outwardly praises by many. Yes his parents did but other than that, he never really did hear good things about himself from others. It felt good to know that someone he loved really did believe in him. “I’d say the same thing about you Tolly. I’m not the only deserving of praise and affection here. You’re one of if not the nicest people I know. You’re a beautiful person, so kind-hearted and warm despite what you’ve been through.”

Tolly went pink at the compliments and pressed close, face finding the crook of Cas' neck so he could be affectionate without having to see that earnest look in his eyes. He pressed kisses there, nuzzled the soft skin and tried to think of what on earth he could say in return. "I… I'm really glad you think so," he finally managed. "You're… you're an amazing person, Cas. You always treat me so well, always make me feel so special." His words were fumbling at first, but they began to smooth out. "I barely know how to deal with it, if I'm being honest. It's all so new."

He laughed softly and tilted his head slightly. “You deserve all the love and affection, Tolly.” He pressed a kiss to his cheek. “Don’t worry, it’s new to me too. But a good kind of new. One I wouldn’t mind if it lasted forever.” He nudged his head gently and pressed a gentleman kiss to his lips. “I love you.”

Tolly flushed slightly and did his best to return the kiss, wrapping an arm around Cas' shoulders to hold him close. "I love you too, Cas." His voice was a little thick, choked up with emotion. "I… um… I know it's a little soon for this, but I honestly don't think I've ever felt this way about someone before."

Cas shook his head and gently nudged Tolly’s head again. “Neither have I. I’ve had a few crushes here and there but never something even close to this.” He said softly, having never really thought about it before. He loved Tolly. Yes the potion did help him realize that he liked being with him but the time after helped he realize that he never wanted to be apart from him again.

It was sort of funny. Tolly hadn't even known he'd liked Cas before the potion, not in any way he would actually let himself feel, and now he would be happy to sit at his feet for the rest of eternity. "Yeah." He rubbed their cheeks together affectionately, a small smile on his face. "Yeah, I… I can't even imagine begin away from you at this point. Guess that potion really worked out for the best, huh?"

“Yeah, it really did.” He replied with a small laugh, drinking in all the affection Tolly offered. “You still owe me for tackling me in the middle of campus.” He teased, combing through Tolly’s hair

Tolly hummed quietly, leaning up to give Cas another soft kiss. He sort of melted when Cas started carding through his hair, letting out a pleased noise and pressing into the touch. "Fine, fine. Will you accept it if I pay you back in affection?"

He kissed back, following Tolly slightly until he pulled away. He laughed softly at the noise and massaged his scalp. He thought for a moment before nodding. “I think that would be fair. Though to be fair, I wouldn’t have wanted that to play out any other way.” He pressed a gentleman kiss to his lips, drawing it out slowly before pulling away with a soft blush