One-on-one (@PPT_SupremeMonarchOfTheAntColony)

Drew walked up behind her, slinging his bag over his shoulder, "Hope she's in."

The door opened to where the latch, attaching it to the frame, would give. A small woman stood there, "Hello?" She said quickly.
"Hi," Drew smiled falsely, "We're here to talk to you about the Lord's loving embrace." He pulled a bible out of his bag, "He can change your life if you'll let him."

Drew nudged Juliette slightly, watching her from the corner of his eye. Susan nodded, "Not today, thank you." and went to close the door only for Drew to stick his foot in the way, "Ma'am, I beg you reconsider, the lord is all loving and will forgive you of all your sins, there is nothing to be afraid of, no reason to turn your back on the light of God."

Susan, who looked very frazzled now, opened the door with shaky hands, "Come in."
"Thank you very much, could I trouble you for a glass of water?" He asked. She merely nodded before retreating to her kitchen. He turned to Juliette, "Are you trying to get us caught or something?"

"It's our job, what did you think we'd have to do when infiltrating the mafia?" He whispered.

"That… would actually be really cool. We should do that next time." He nodded.

"What?" He questioned just as Susan came back with the glass of water. "Thank you," He said taking the glass from her, he took a sip. "As I was saying the Lord will forgive you, he is loving and merciful."

"God cares about every one of us, including you," He pointed at Susan, "You just have to believe in him and he will reward you."

"Shall we take this to your living room?" He asks, craning his neck to look past the woman.
"Sure," She said, leading them into the said room. She sat on a couch, Drew sitting next to her, opening the bible and explaining some of the passages.

He opened his bag silently, slipping out a knife that he hid behind him. "and that's how Jesus gave up his life as a scapegoat for our sins." He explained, waiting for the perfect moment to strike.

"Do you want some cake?" Susan asked, completely calm now, completely unexpecting.
"I think that would be divine," Drew replied smiling kindly, but just as Susan got up he quickly stabbed his knife through her neck and she fell back.
He swallowed thickly, his shaking hands pulling the knife out and cutting one of her fingers off. He put both in separate bags, taking out his burner phone and snapping a quick photo before dropping that in his bag as well. He remembered the bible and, not wanting to leave and fingerprints he shoved it in his bag too. He zipped his bag shut and walked into the hallway, nodding to Juliette, trying hard to keep his composure.

"Can we go?" He said, trying his best to hide his shaking hands and the tears in his eyes, "and can you drive?" He asked, his breathing becoming faster.

"Thanks," He replied, they left the house and got into the car. He shoved the bag in the seat behind him before turning back to face the front. He sat stiffly, his still shaking hands lying palm up in his lap.

"Yeah, we can wait until we're both ready." He said quietly, almost to the point where he couldn't be heard.

"Thanks," He ducked into the car. He tried his best to put on the seatbelt without spreading to much blood, eventually, he was able to do it.